Essentiality of Standard Essential Patents (SEPs) in Patent Portfolio Assessment
Recently, we were given an opportunity by a client that is a pioneer in its field to evaluate its patent portfolio vis a vis other player in the market. While evaluating a portfolio, the most challenging task is to identify the hidden gems in a river full of pebbles. But with the right strategy, methodology, and an experienced team, this arduous task can be easily executed. We put together a team of 5-6 infringement experts in the technology domain to analyze the client portfolio.
TTC Approach – We at TTC follow the 5-step approach.

How TTC Added Value
Our 5-step approach is a well-researched, structured, foolproof approach that has been developed and has always worked well for us and our clients. The result of this portfolio assessment was ten comprehensive evidence of use claim charts that were shared with the client. The client was happy, consequently, so were we.
But, we wanted to give the client more than was asked for. But the client’s query had been answered. What more could we do? We sat down as a team and went back to the drawing board to brainstorm on how we could add more value to our client’s business. Ideas flowed aplenty. Until someone suggested the exploration of the SEPs in the client portfolio.
This got the team excited and fired up. We all know the value Standard Essential Patents add to a company. The value addition phase began with us checking the standards covered in the client’s portfolio. It was tougher than we thought it would be, but we were relentless. Armed with the information we unearthed, extracted Standard Essential Patents from the client portfolio, and identified corresponding standard-compliant products of competitors in the marketplace.
Our next step was to compare the claims of patents with the specifications of a declared standard.
While checking the essentiality of the patent, the most important point is to identify whether the claimed subject matter is an optional or mandatory feature to the standard (as this would greatly influence the positive availability of the same feature in the target product) and if there is any licensing agreement between the target competitors and the patent holder. After verifying this and before preparing claim charts, we checked all versions of the standards for the relevant subject matter considering the date restrictions. With this strategy, we were able to prepare 8 new claim charts, and increase the value of our client’s portfolio.
By going the extra mile, not only did we have a happy client, but we also had a happy client whose happiness translated into an increased budget for the project.
We came away with a lesson for ourselves too! Standard Essential Patents, which are so often taken for granted play a significant role in a Patent Portfolio Assessment Project and serve to strengthen a patent portfolio more than they are given credit for.
For us at TTC adding value is an important part of everything we do. This leads to us customizing roach for each client by constantly developing strategies and methods that work best.
Get in touch with TT Consultants for a Patent Portfolio Assessment that shows you all the hidden gems in your patent portfolio.
Recently, we were given an opportunity by a client that is a pioneer in its field to evaluate its patent portfolio vis a vis another player in the market. While evaluating a portfolio, the most challenging task is to identify the hidden gems in a river full of pebbles. But with the right strategy, methodology, and an experienced team, this arduous task can be easily executed. We put together a team of 5-6 infringement experts in the technology domain to analyze the client portfolio.
Shivani Mittal
Recent Posts
Categories
- Automobile Industry21 Posts
- Case Studies5 Posts
- Chemical7 Posts
- Competitor Benchmarking8 Posts
- Consumer Products29 Posts
- Corporate52 Posts
- Design Search4 Posts
- Freedom to Operate13 Posts
- Geographical2 Posts
- Infringement Search34 Posts
- Intellectual Property (IP)152 Posts
- Invalidation13 Posts
- Inventor1 Posts
- IP Trends119 Posts
- Landscape Analysis11 Posts
- Latest Technology50 Posts
- Life Sciences36 Posts
- Mechanical Engineering3 Posts
- Medical Devices3 Posts
- Mergers and Acquisitions4 Posts
- Metaverse(AR/VR)7 Posts
- Patent Drafting & Illustrations56 Posts
- Patent Monitoring20 Posts
- Patent Portfolio Commercialization22 Posts
- Patent Portfolio Management48 Posts
- Patent Prosecution56 Posts
- Patentability Search37 Posts
- Pharmaceuticals3 Posts
- Semiconductor and Electronics4 Posts
- Smartphone Technology3 Posts
- Standard Essential Patents (SEP)9 Posts
- State of the Art10 Posts
- Technology113 Posts
- Technology Scouting7 Posts
- Telecummunication3 Posts