Intellectual Property Concerns In Augmented Reality
Augmented reality (AR) is the latest buzzword in technological circles owing to its ability to transform the way businesses and individuals learn, work, and play. Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality are both crucial components of the Metaverse that promises to create a single, universal, and immersive virtual world.
While the time is ripe for new tech, these strides of development are being weighed down by challenges facing them. Since the quick advancements in tech are not matched by changes in IP laws and regulations, the road ahead seems tough for innovators.
Table of Contents
IP Challenges In AR Tech
The emergence and dissipation of both AR and VR in several sectors have already begun to present new IP issues for innovators, businesses, consumers, and courts of law. Much like the rise of the internet that necessitated cyber laws in the 1990s, these new areas too, require legal scrutiny. Patent litigations have already started in this domain, and as it extends to newer aspects of our lives, these challenges will only intensify.
While AR and VR are both software that uses the internet to showcase a virtual world, they work in different ways and thus have unique IP laws issues associated with them. To understand this, we must first learn what distinguishes the two techs.
In AR, the real world is used as a backdrop and blends digital elements into it, usually with the use of a smartphone. By overlaying digital content onto real-life scenarios, it enriches the user experience and creates an interactive environment.
VR, on the other hand, is an entirely simulated experience built from the ground up. It is used to generate images, sounds, and other sensations in a virtual world. Thus, VR is a fully immersive experience that can only be accessed using specially designed headsets.
Applications Of AR
There are several examples of AR that we see around us. The virtual ball trail in a game of cricket, the first down marker in football, shown with a virtual yellow line, or the famous Pokemon Go game that had people walk around with their heads buried in their smartphones looking for Pokemon. Other areas where AR can be useful include:
- Healthcare – Using AR, doctors can identify the precise position of making an incision or inserting an implant in 3D. This increases the success rate of surgeries, especially in cases where the area is difficult to see or visualize. AR simulators can also be used to train doctors in performing surgeries.
- Travel & Tourism – Hotels have begun using AR to give guests room tours and advertise their offerings. It can help offer information about a city, including monuments to visit, places to eat, transportation schedules, etc., that will enhance the traveling experience for tourists. It also allows you to bring historical sights to life by envisioning how they looked when they were built.
- Interior Designing/ Architecture – Homebuilders can use AR for the integration of design and construction teams using 3D models. It can be used by interior decorators to show their clients what a restyled room will exactly look like once finished. Realtors will find it useful in presenting a 3D version of an empty house to buyers rather than decorating the place.
- Education – Learning can be made more interesting by incorporating the extraordinary interactive experience offered by AR. It will allow teachers to show 3D models and virtual examples that will help students memorize and learn faster. Businesses can also use the tech to create training modules for employees that can be accessed remotely.
- Fashion/Retail – The retail sector has been revolutionized by the application of AR. Customers can now make quicker and smarter decisions by virtually trying out and customizing items. This will especially help online shoppers who can interact with the brand and its products in a more personalized manner.
- Entertainment – By merging the real world with the virtual one, AR offers a powerful means of adding a new dimension to entertainment. It will allow audiences to become active rather than passive members of shows. Walt Disney parks are now using AR on rides and attractions to provide guests with an immersive and interactive experience. AR is one of the fastest-growing trends in the entertainment and gaming industry with limitless potential.
Patents In AR
Patent filing for AR is the same as other technologies, but differences arise when dealing with user interfaces like AR hardware and motion-tracking technologies. Tech giants like Microsoft, Samsung, Google, LG, Sony, etc., have successfully filed and published patents related to AR and VR headsets. The areas where patents are being filed extend beyond the hardware to method claims for the practical applications of AR tech as discussed in the above use cases.
AR patent infringement cases have already begun springing up in courts. ESP, Inc. v. HTC Corp., Case No. 3:17-cv-05806 (N.D. Cal.) was one such case that dealt with the issue. ESP claimed that HTC’s Vive headset infringed on three patents. HTC moved to dismiss the claims as impermissible due to being a patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. §101. The courts decided the case based on the eligibility standards set by the Alice Framework and found ESP’s patents to pass the test and thus contain eligible subject matter.
A case related to the application of AR was filed by Lennon Image Technologies LLC (“Lennon”) against retailers like Macy’s, and Bloomingdale’s alleged infringement. The retailers were using a webcam tech that allowed users to try on products by superimposing them on their images. While the defendants claimed that this tech was different from Lennon’s patent, ultimately, they removed the feature from their sites settled.
The rising litigation is also turning into a matter of concern as several NPEs are spearheading campaigns that could result in stifling innovation. In the above case, Lennon Technologies, an NPE, was successfully able to prevent the retail use of its tech in the retail segment.
The litigation trend in AR patents poses critical questions about the detailed description of claimed uses of AR that will be required in the patent specification to satisfy the written description and enablement requirements of Section 112. Courts are increasingly rejecting patents for their inability to satisfy either written description or enablement. The solution could be to furnish as many potential uses and applications as possible. But it is possible that some aspects of the tech may become valuable as AR evolves, and it is not impossible to peek into the future. Therefore, just as the U.S. Federal Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) did for antibody patents, it is time for the patent offices to provide precise guidelines for meeting 112 requirements in the case of AR and VR technology.
Copyrights & Trademarks
Trademark infringement in AR is likely to increase as this tech pervades various aspects of our daily lives. Virtual trademarks can be used anywhere in the virtual world, thereby creating serious legal issues. The advertiser may or may not be the legal owner of the trademark and this will make it difficult for the users to establish authenticity.
In Marvel Enterprises, Inc. v. NCSoft Corp., the latter created a video game with avatars and heroic outfits that were similar to Marvel’s superheroes. However, the court rejected Marvel’s claim on the grounds that the names were not used in a business sense or directly in conjunction with the product’s sale, distribution, or promotion, and thus did not constitute trademark violation.
Brands like Nike, Gucci, and Prada are already registering their trademarks in classes specifically relating to virtual goods for use in AR/VR environments. Copyright law too would see new challenges in the fair and authorized use of works. Considering that AR has the capability to amplify sounds, if somebody records a distant concert and corrects the sound levels, would it amount to a copyright violation? This is just the beginning of an era that is going to expose a complex set of legal and IP issues in the near future.
The legal, social, and ethical challenges that could emerge from the use of AR and VR tech can prove a nightmare for safeguarding IP. IP lawyers and businesses need to be extra cautious when drafting patent applications or licensing agreements in order to cover as many bases as possible. Till the time legal guidelines become clearer and designed to address AR/VR issues, precaution seems the only cure!
At TT Consultants, our distinctive approach is centered around our hybrid solution that blends the power of AI-enabled XLSOUT technology with human expertise. This unparalleled combination allows us to offer top-notch solutions for your intellectual property management requirements.
Our team comprises skilled professionals, including experienced IP professionals, who are passionate about constant innovation and development. We take pride in our ability to IMPROVISE, ADAPT, and IMPLEMENT customized and strategic solutions that cater to the unique needs of our clients.
TT Consultants offers a range of efficient, high-quality solutions for your intellectual property management ranging from
- Patentability Search
- Invalidation Search
- FTO (Freedom to Operate)
- Patent Portfolio Management
- Patent Monitoring
- Patent Infringement Search
- Patent Drafting & Illustrations
and much more. We provide both law firms and corporations in many industries with turnkey solutions.Contact Us